The fatal snorkelling incident at Mengalum Island on September 23, 2026, in which a Chinese tourist died during a guided water activity, has drawn sharp scrutiny to the regulatory framework governing tourist safety at Sabah’s offshore island destinations. The death has prompted Sabah lawmakers and political representatives to publicly demand clarity on which government agencies bear responsibility for monitoring and enforcing safety standards at the island — and whether existing oversight mechanisms are adequate to prevent future tragedies.
Multi-Agency Accountability at Mengalum Island Remains Unclear, Warisan Leader Warns
Warisan vice-president Datuk Junz Wong, responding to the September 23 incident, stated that tourist safety at Mengalum Island cannot rest with any single regulatory body. He called for defined coordination among at least five agencies: Kota Kinabalu City Hall (DBKK, or Dewan Bandaraya Kota Kinabalu), the Sabah Lands and Surveys Department, the Ministry of Tourism, Culture and Environment Sabah (KePKAS), the Ministry of Tourism, Arts and Culture Malaysia (Motac), and other relevant authorities.
Wong’s statement identified what analysts and lawmakers describe as a structural gap in Sabah’s island tourism oversight model — one where multiple agencies hold partial jurisdiction but no single body exercises comprehensive, end-to-end accountability for visitor safety at offshore destinations.
“The issue is not only whether the boat operator and vessel were properly licensed,” Wong said. “We must also ask whether the tourism activities and facilities at the destination itself have the necessary approvals and whether the relevant safety procedures were properly implemented.”
Wong additionally called on DBKK to disclose its procedures for operators using its public jetty, specifically whether licences and approvals were verified before tourists were transported to Mengalum Island.
Demand for Island Tourism Safety Standards Rises as Incident Highlights Procedural Gaps
The Mengalum snorkelling death has renewed scrutiny over whether operators serving Sabah’s offshore islands conduct adequate pre-activity safety briefings, supply sufficient safety equipment, and deploy trained personnel capable of responding to water emergencies. Wong called explicitly for preventive enforcement — rather than reactive action — describing the current approach as insufficient.
“Preventive enforcement is needed rather than action only after an incident occurred,” he said, urging authorities to conduct a comprehensive inspection of all operators currently serving Mengalum Island.
The call reflects broader concerns within Sabah’s tourism sector, where island day-trip operators serve large volumes of domestic and international visitors. Questions raised following the September 23 death include whether tourists received proper safety briefings before entering the water, whether adequate lifesaving equipment was on board or at the site, and whether trained personnel were present and positioned to monitor snorkelling activity and respond to emergencies in real time.
Land Status and Licensing at Mengalum Island Require Separate Clarification, Assemblyman Asserts
Luyang assemblyman Samuel Wong called for the status of land tenure and tourism facility approvals at Mengalum Island to be addressed as a distinct matter, separate from the ongoing police investigation into the tourist’s death. He emphasised that land status questions should not be conflated with causation — but that regulatory clarity remains necessary regardless of the investigation’s outcome.
“To be clear, we are not saying that the land status or TOL was the cause of the tourist’s death. There must be evidence before any such connection can be made,” Samuel said, referring to Temporary Occupation Licences (TOL), which govern land use at certain coastal and island sites in Sabah.
Samuel urged the Sabah Lands and Surveys Department to clarify whether any TOL or land occupation at Mengalum was current and properly authorised, and whether structures, jetties, and tourism facilities used by operators carried the necessary approvals from KePKAS and Motac. He further called for disclosure of the specific licensing and safety requirements applicable to operators running snorkelling activities at the island.
Regulatory Review Urged as Recurring Safety Weaknesses at Offshore Island Sites Draw Scrutiny
Both Datuk Junz Wong and Samuel Wong called on relevant authorities to review previous safety incidents at Mengalum Island, with the stated aim of identifying any recurring weaknesses in oversight or enforcement. The joint statement from the two representatives framed the September 23 death not as an isolated event but as a prompt for systemic review of Sabah’s tourism safety and enforcement architecture.
“The death of a tourist is deeply saddening. We respect the police investigation and will not prejudge the outcome. But the incident must also prompt a serious review of the existing tourism safety and enforcement system,” both said. “Every agency must understand and carry out its responsibility, and any regulatory or safety gaps must be addressed before another tragedy occurs.”
The police investigation into the September 23 death remains ongoing. Authorities have not yet issued public findings on the circumstances of the incident, the licensing status of the operator involved, or the safety protocols — if any — that were in place at the time of the tourist’s death at Mengalum Island.
The agencies named in the lawmakers’ statements — DBKK, the Sabah Lands and Surveys Department, KePKAS, and Motac — had not issued formal responses at the time of publication.
About the Author
